Skip to Content
Playing GTA VI? Here's what an historian wants you to pay attention to
Vice City, the fictionalized version of Miami featured in Grand Theft Auto VI. (Image courtesy of Rockstar Games.)

Playing GTA VI? Here's what an historian wants you to pay attention to

From the streets of Vice City to the rules that govern gameplay, an FIU historian explains how video games shape our understanding of history, places and people.

November 20, 2026 at 3:59pm


Did your university make it into Grand Theft Auto VI? What about your neighborhood, your high school or your favorite local restaurant?

For South Floridians exploring the game's fictionalized Miami, part of the excitement is discovering how the places that make up their everyday lives have been recreated in the virtual world of Vice City.

But every familiar building, every recognizable neighborhood and every glaringly absent landmark reflects a design choice about how to portray Miami. So do the people who inhabit the game and the activities players can engage in.

It was through conversations with her students that Lindsey Maxwell, an associate teaching professor in FIU’s Department of History, became interested in how video games shape people's understanding of the past. Students who demonstrated detailed knowledge of historical periods often told her they had acquired that knowledge through games such as Red Dead Redemption 2 and Call of Duty.

She developed a course, History Through Gaming, in which students examine how video games present and interpret history through storytelling and gameplay.

In the following Q&A, Maxwell offers a historian's perspective on what to look for, what questions to ask and how to make sense of GTA VI's fictionalized Miami. Her parting advice to players suggests that what they cannot do in the game may be as revealing as what they can.

What would a historian pay attention to when exploring GTA VI's version of Miami?

A fictionalized Miami is best read as an imagined geography. It condenses the city into a recognizable atmosphere or “vibe”, a mediated place built from decades of film, television and earlier games as much as from Miami itself.

I'd be looking at what the architecture looks like, what the communities and people look and sound like, what they're wearing and what kind of story the game is telling about its main characters and the character of the city.

Every choice is making an argument about the place. It's telling you what the designers think makes Miami meaningful, memorable or entertaining.

I would like to see the diversity of Miami, not just Brickell and the high-rises or some of the more recognizable parts of South Florida, but everything in between. There are really interesting, beautiful parts of Miami that aren't as well known but are nonetheless very important to its culture and history.

Miami has a long history of Indigenous presence, historically Black communities, successive waves of Caribbean and Latin American migration, and environmental transformation.

I'd be interested in whether the game gives those histories texture and context or uses them mainly as scenery.

 GTA VI Vice City SkylineVice City by day. (Image courtesy of Rockstar Games.)

Lindsey MaxwellLindsey B. Maxwell is an Assistant Teaching Professor who specializes in the history of faith, politics, and education. Maxwell’s current project investigates the rise of homeschooling in 1970s America to clarify its cultural and political impact on present-day education. Maxwell has contributed to the National Council for the Social Sciences and other educational conferences with talks on tech-assisted online teaching and the use of virtual reality in history education.

You describe the choices that game-developers make as historical arguments. How do video games make those arguments?

Games show how people imagine the past and make it meaningful in the present. They do this by building worlds, establishing rules and asking players to act within a system.

Unlike film or literature, games offer a high level of interactivity to consumers. The mechanics themselves and the constraints players operate under can make a historical argument. We call this procedural rhetoric.

Take the original Oregon Trail, for example. It’s a game about the westward expansion of the United States during the 19th century. The mechanics of the game are focused on pioneer survival: hunting, managing supplies and making decisions about how to survive the journey westward.

By emphasizing those activities and largely leaving out stories of Indigenous land ownership and sovereignty, the game makes an argument about the origins of the United States, that we were born out of struggle, survival and rugged individualism.

More recent versions of the game have gone to great lengths to address this, which also shows how these cultural artifacts are products of their time.

A game need not be a reliable representation of the past to be valuable evidence. Like any primary source, it can be read as a document of the cultural moment and the assumptions of the people who produced it.

You've studied another Rockstar Games title, Red Dead Redemption 2. What can it tell us about how a game like GTA VI might portray Miami?

Red Dead Redemption 2 is an interesting game because, in many ways, it tries to challenge some of the mythological aspects of the American West while still allowing players to experience that mythology. You're playing an outlaw in the American West, and there's an element of individualism and freedom that I think has a really strong appeal for people around the world.

But the game also brings a richness and complexity to the history of the American West.

There's a Native American subplot involving a father and son who have different opinions about how they should engage with the federal government and which actions to take. Telling the story in that way gives a fullness to those characters that we often only give to main characters.

It's still mythic in its setting and context, but you're giving a richness to the people of the past.

Miami, with all the things it stereotypically represents in terms of wealth, excess and upward mobility, encapsulates the grittier side of the American dream. In GTA VI, that tension is written into the story itself. The protagonists are hemmed in by bad credit, payday lenders and a family house-flipping scheme gone wrong, even as the city around them promises easy money.

I could see that being one of the reasons people around the world might be drawn to playing out that fantasy.

What would be interesting to see is whether GTA VI challenges and complicates that mythology in the way Red Dead Redemption 2 did with the American West.

Beyond the setting and storyline, what can the way we play GTA VI tell us about society?

Interactivity changes the player's position from spectator to participant. Players don't simply watch or read about events unfolding; they act within a responsive system.

That agency is designed and bounded, however. The game defines which actions are available, which are foreclosed and what consequences follow.

One of the things we talk about in my course is the tension between individual agency and social structures. Games can overemphasize the amount of agency an individual has at a particular historical moment because limiting that agency might make the game less enjoyable.

Rules can suggest what the game treats as valuable, risky, legitimate or possible. Systems around money, property, violence, law and opportunity can make particular ideas about society feel natural or inevitable. In GTA VI, witnesses can describe a player's clothes or car, cameras capture their appearance, and players manage a family savings account. Those rules about surveillance and money quietly teach players how this world works.

A game might reward individual competition, for example, while giving less attention to collective action or structural limits. That doesn't mean every player will read the rules the same way, but the rules are still part of the game's argument about how its world works.

Could GTA VI itself become a historical artifact?

Future historians could study the game as evidence of how people in the 2020s imagined cities, crime, wealth, technology, migration and social life.

Like any work of fiction, it would be read as a cultural artifact that registers the anxieties, desires and assumptions of its moment, not as a record of events. For example, GTA VI’s satire of wellness influencers and its in-game social media feeds are exactly the kinds of details a future historian of the 2020s would find revealing, because they capture contemporary perceptions of how performative, mediated and monetized everyday life had become.

One of the questions you ask of any historical source is: Who made this? Why? What's the motive? Who's the audience? All the answers to those questions give you a better idea of how to assess it.

Commercial motives don't diminish a game's value as historical evidence. They help explain why certain stories, images and mechanics are foregrounded and others left out.

Historians would also need more than the game itself: earlier versions, updates, promotional materials, reviews, interviews, player discussions and records of how people played it.

The game's changing software and online features make preservation especially important. What players experience at launch may not be identical to what later players encounter.

What advice would you give someone about to play GTA VI?

Enjoy the game, first off, but also make note of the choices that you have and the choices you don't have, and the stories that are told and the stories that are left out.

There are always choices in any medium that's presenting history or society. And it's a valuable exercise to ask why and to what effect.

Vice City Influencer(Image courtesy of Rockstar Games.)